Restoring Virtue to Finance
Setup
Finance is the engine of capitalism, according to Harvard economist Mihir Desai. Finance is what makes our whole economy tick, and its 600 year history is filled with success stories. Has finance reached a point, though, where its pervasiveness has become a weakness? John Dickerson, correspondent for CBS News’ “60 Minutes,” sits down with Desai to dig into what those working in finance should do to restore what Desai says the financial sector has lost.
Saving finance from itself
Capitalism wouldn’t function the way it does without the mechanisms that finance creates, says author and Harvard economist Mihir Desai. Put simply, finance moves capital from those who have it to those who need it. Desai says that when finance works as it should, the results are unparalleled. But, he warns, finance done poorly can have major consequences. Desai explains how finance has drifted, and why it needs to be reined in:
Desai points fingers at what’s called value extraction — that, investors or businesses whose main focus is capturing value for themselves, not creating more for everyone (value creation). Desai compares value to a pie, and value extractors want to grab as much of the pie as possible, instead of helping to grow the pie for everyone.
Big IdeaA lot of the problems that people perceive in capitalism today…have to do with how finance has changed in the past 30 years.Mihir Desai
Finance and the human condition
In order to understand the stakes of what’s at play when finance goes awry, Mihir Desai digs into the long history of capitalism and finance. Starting with prototype insurance companies and investment groups, Desai says finance has grown inextricably alongside our modern understanding of both society and humanity:
There’s a human face to finance that Desai claims capitalism would do well to remember. Spreadsheets, tables, and crunching numbers are great tools, but the abstractions they represent don’t capture the full picture of the humanity underlying it all.
Breaking free from the investor mentality
So what happened over the past century that set finance on its current course? Mihir Desai traces it back to an unlikely culprit: the investment management industry that grew out of pension funds. Pension funds gave enormous amounts of money to investment managers — so much money, in fact, that their way of doing things became the default. Desai and John Dickerson explain further:
This exchange has been lightly edited for clarity
-
Mihir Desai: [The investment management industry’s] way of thinking about the world has come to dominate. That’s in everything. It’s in the way we think about share buybacks, it’s in the way we do social programs… How do we do nonprofits today? Everyone has to have an ROI. If you don’t have a return on investment model in your not-for-profit, you got a problem. That’s the dominance of an investor mentality, and when you come to think of it, it’s kind of absurd.
-
John Dickerson: But wouldn't people say we’re leveraging the investor mentality to do good things?
-
Mihir Desai: We are, but there is this sense in which we’ve contorted social policy and not-for-profits to have an investor mentality. So low income housing is a great example — that is the way we build low-income housing. If you think about a problem in the country that is really severe, it is housing shortages for low-income [communities]... And yet we really do it in this really weird, perverse way, which is that we sell tax credits to investors so that they can decide where to put low-income housing. It’s a complete Rube Goldberg machine, yet that’s the way it gets done.
Desai says investment managers dictate the rules because they hold so much sway over the economy, and that’s a problem. Desai explains that one way of solving one problem in society isn’t the solution to every problem.
The micro and macro of fixing investment
Despite his critiques of the US financial system, Mihir Desai says that a handful of adjustments would go a long way to course-correcting the bedrock of capitalism. There’s a micro, he says, and there’s a macro:
On the more discrete level, Desai explains that investment managers need to make their decisions based off more than spreadsheets and statistics — they need to return humanity to finance. And on a larger scale, pension fund managers will have to take a more active role in deciding how and where their capital gets used. Otherwise, it’s too easily taken advantage of by the sort of value extractors that Desai says are leaching off true value creators.
Learn More
Additional Information
Resources
"Wisdom of Finance: Discovering Humanity in the World of Risk and Return" by Mihir Desai
Explore More
Society
Friends, partners, children, families, coworkers — these connections profoundly shape our lives, and even in the best of times, navigating them takes real work. It also means...
New York Times columnist and bestselling author David Brooks is known for bringing his thoughtful reflections on politics and culture, but at this year’s Aspen Ideas Festival,...
Jump in by watching our 15 most popular talks of all time. From black holes to jazz and civil rights to psychology hacks, we've collected the talks that remain audience favori...
Finding the national and global headlines understandably bleak lately? Whether you need mental distraction or stimulation, engross yourself in compelling topics and get a gli...
The United States spends $4.3 trillion—almost one fifth of the nation’s GDP—on health care. As the scale of the medical enterprise expands, venture capitalists are pursuing th...
Today's kids are coming of age against a backdrop of political, social, technological and economic upheaval. While these circumstances are shaping a precocious generation that...
Hope seems like a simple concept, but the feeling can be difficult to hold onto. And when times are difficult and chaos swirls around us, it’s more important than ever. How do...
Advocates, healthcare providers, legislators, researchers, and venture capitalists are bringing the unique health needs of women to light – from vigorous policy debates on iss...
Ethical dilemmas, stakeholder pressure, building trust — leading organizations requires wisdom and stamina from the top. Who wouldn’t want some advice?
What makes us happy — really? How can we raise resilient and empathetic children? What does it mean to be truly connected in our increasingly digital world? Can we re-instill...
In a time of growing wealth disparity and changing societal values, can capitalism adapt? How is the economy being transformed by investments in infrastructure, AI, energy, an...
Our need for human connection is profound and deep. Yet, today, one in two adults are living with measurable levels of loneliness – and the numbers are even higher among young...
Conflict and suffering can bring out the worst in people, but it can also bring out the best. This is one of the lessons New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof has learned...
The federal right to abortions in the United States has been overturned, access to contraception and IVF services are threatened in many states, and the gender wage gap persis...
Henry Louis Gates Jr. — one of America’s leading public intellectuals and director of the Hutchins Center for African and African American Research at Harvard — explains the i...
A nonbinary comedian challenges us to question our notions of self, gender and society, and opens our eyes to what we may gain in the process.
Why do some conversations succeed while others stumble? The neurology and psychology of communication offer surprising explanations for why human connection goes right or wron...
In a time of growing wealth disparity and evolving societal values, can capitalism adapt to sustain the American Dream?
The rollback of reproductive rights, the push to end no-fault divorce, and gun laws that allow domestic abusers to own a firearm are turning the clock back on women’s rights....
Women are twice as likely to invest in female-led businesses. Explore the ways women approach wealth building and investment, and how they create opportunities to build financ...