Is Antitrust the Antidote to Big Tech?
Setup
In the United States, there is growing debate over the role of antitrust and competition policy in protecting competition and American consumers. Digital platforms, corporate mergers, and consolidation are profoundly changing the global competitive landscape. Can antitrust law temper the power of digital platforms like Google and Facebook? Is the current antitrust legal regime equipped for the 21st Century? Journalist Charles Duhigg explores these topics with Makan Delrahim, head of the U.S. Department of Justice Antitrust Division.
Has the government dropped the ball by not going after big tech?
Delrahim says no, because there needs to be evidence that competition has been threatened. If and when there’s supporting evidence, the government should take action, he says. His view is that in a healthy free market you want investors to invest in big tech because they are providing the actual competition to the old-line standard-bearers of many industries.
Big IdeaThe Supreme Court has guided us that just being big is not bad. Being big and behaving badly is bad. We don’t want to punish somebody we’ve encouraged to compete.Makan Delrahim
If it's free, should the consumer be concerned?
How should we determine consumer welfare when so many things, like Google’s search and Facebook’s networking, are given away for free? If these platforms are giving away something for free, isn’t the consumer benefitting? It helps to take a look back at how we got here.
Who knew?
Is antitrust going to be the solution for big tech?
There are a lot of concerns from small companies feeling edged out by Amazon and Google. Should they be looking beyond antitrust for a solution? It’s complicated, says Delrahim. But vigorous and timely antitrust enforcement, backed by a court that understands economics, is a system of law that works.
The Takeaway
Explore More
Health
This week marks one year since the first known COVID-19 death. And while the remarkable pace of vaccine development is widely praised, the lag in its distribution is concernin...
As the nation reels from the attack on the Capitol, we look for ideas that will move us forward.
Peggy Clark asks Dan Glickman to reflect on this past year and to share what he expects from our country under President-elect Joe Biden’s leadership.
“We are not in a rush to pull people back into the workplace,” says Rob Falzon
NPR's Tamara Keith and Dan Glickman discuss what a Biden agenda might look like.
Newark Mayor Ras Baraka’s family has called the city home for over 100 years.
On November 9, 2020, as coronavirus cases surge, President-elect Joe Biden named a COVID-19 Advisory Council. Aspen Ideas has been honored to host several of the council membe...
Poet Claudia Rankine discusses the urgency of reimagining what it means to be American with Eric Liu.
Not by shying away from arguments but by embracing them. Arguments are our legacy and our shared history.
