Does Great Art Speak for Itself?
Setup
We are often told great art speaks for itself. In practice, though, helping visual art find an audience usually requires a skillful narrative. How should we understand this use of storytelling, and who does it best? Does surging interest in contemporary art present special opportunities and responsibilities for developing appreciative audiences? What are key strategies and challenges in a time when arbiters of creative value — including museums and auction houses — serve constituents across the spectrum of artists, viewers, buyers and the larger public realm?
- 2019 Festival
- Arts
- Full transcript
Display, interpret, or both?
Wall texts that explain a piece of art are a relatively new sight in museums, says Kate D. Levin, panel moderator and principal at Bloomberg Associates. And although they’ve been hailed as a democratizing force in institutions that were previously seen as oppressively esoteric, others in the art world think that truly great art shouldn’t need explanation or contextualization. Michael Govan, director of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, explains how his museum decides how to annotate its exhibits:
The limits of art for art’s sake
The patrons of the Pérez Art Museum Miami don’t fit the mold of usual art museum regulars, says museum director Franklin Sirmans. With that in mind, Sirmans sees his role to create exhibits that move beyond an assumption of patent meaning or depth in the works of art:
Of course Sirmans wants his patrons to have that “a-ha” moment when they see a particularly impactful piece of art. But he also wants to bring art to everyone, including people for whom art isn’t a language they speak well. He sees power in using art museums as a place for dialogue, not just as a place to experience art for art’s sake.
Big IdeaWe want to take advantage of the [art museum] being a space for dialogue, for conversation. A place that can have the kind of conversations that don’t happen in other places in the world.Franklin Sirmans
Art collecting in the era of investment art
Art collectors play a very specific gatekeeping role in determining what is and isn’t great art in the popular imagination. If artists are reliant on sales for their livelihoods, then their livelihoods are at the mercy of the tastes of art collectors. According to Allan Schwartzman, chairman of Global Fine Arts for Sotheby's, we are living in an era of profuse art collection. Wealth is getting more consolidated, and a large cadre of art collectors is emerging that sees art collection as an investment more than an appreciative endeavor. Schwartzman says that it’s having profound effects on the art world.
Big Idea[Valuable art] is becoming more defined by the opinion of a small group of influential people within the marketplace rather than through a more complex network of interpreters that’s existed in the past.Allan Schwartzman
Using art as an investment strategy is chilling the ability of many artists to take creative risks. If they create art that this new generation of collectors think won’t hold value, they are in danger of not selling their artwork at the prices they need to sustain themselves.
Who knew?
What’s the future of the museum?
Retail spaces in museums, more interactive exhibits, edgier subject matter — art museums are adapting to the zeitgeist of the 21st century. But what effect does that have on how people experience the art itself, and should we be welcoming these changes? Franklin Sirmans weighs in:
Learn More
Additional Information
Explore More
Arts
Museums are typically testaments to the past, but a growing number are using exhibitions to shape our response to the future—specifically to climate change. Museum leaders wil...
Storytelling, music, animation, and podcasts! Watch the magic of innovative content being born as creatives pitch their ideas to a panel of Planet Media judges, each hoping to...
William Shakespeare started writing plays in an era when popular theater was exploding and cementing its place in culture. Audiences spanned economic classes, professions and...
The stories we hear about migrants trying to escape difficult circumstances tend to focus on hardship, conflict, statistics and policy. We rarely get a deep look at any of the...
Whether expressed through systems that are easy to navigate, devices that are friendly to their users, and spaces that are pleasing to the eye, thoughtful design can break dow...
Shakespeare is ubiquitous in literature classes and theater, but the avenues of relating to his work are not always clear to young people and modern audiences. Some, such as S...
October is National Book Month, and we’re celebrating by looking back at some of our favorite conversations about reading and writing from the Aspen Ideas Festival and Aspen I...
Like Photoshop, photography, or even pigment, A.I. represents new technology for creative expression that aims to close the gap between imagination and physicality. Alexander...
Journalist Tom Friedman reflects on 28 years of reporting.
NBCUniversal News Group recently announced the honorees for its prime-time special, “Inspiring America: The Inspiration List.” NBC News’ Tom Llamas brings this conversation fe...
“Self-care” is the buzzword of the moment. But far before face masks and digital detoxes, ancient philosophers were thinking of ways to enhance human flourishing. How do their...
HBO’s hit show “Succession” is the latest example of how well the themes of tragedy, betrayal, ambition, and love — which Shakespeare depicted for the stage centuries before e...
For Kate Levin of Bloomberg Philanthropies, Mayor Melvin Carter of St. Paul Minnesota, and Karen Brunwasser of FeelBeit (a community center that bridges divides between East...
As the impacts of climate change become more evident on natural habitats, widespread focus on protecting these places is more critical than ever. With Hollywood finally flexin...
The search for meaning is at the crux of the human condition and the basis of Life Worth Living, a new book emulating one of Yale’s most popular courses. In this lively “hot s...
The Afternoon of Conversation is the Aspen Ideas Festival's pinnacle programming moment. Over 2,000 people gather in the Benedict Music Tent, an open-air venue with acoustics...
Jenna Bush Hager sits down with best-selling author Amor Towles to discuss his latest book, The Lincoln Highway, and the winding road that led him to writing. (Book signing to...
From “The Office” to being cheerleader for spirituality, comedic actor, writer, and producer Rainn Wilson is on a mission to show the world how embracing spirituality can help...
Javier Zamora’s migration journey took him from El Salvador to the United States by foot at age nine, while Jamie Ford’s great-grandfather emigrated from China to Nevada to mi...
Join best-selling author Amor Towles, moderator Don Katz, and fellow readers for an engaging discussion of Towles’s Audible original story: a stylish and alluring tale of art,...