

The Mysterious Mind of the Dog
Setup
For years, dogs have been getting the short end of the stick — so to speak — when it comes to research. Dolphins and primates get lots of attention. Now, it’s the dog’s turn. Two experts, Alexandra Horowitz and Brian Hare, are part of a growing number of scientists researching canine cognition. They study what a dog knows, understands, and believes. Sure, it’s nice to know what it means when your pooch wags his tail, licks your face, or stops to sniff. But understanding a dog’s mind is becoming increasingly vital as canines take on more jobs, such as finding bombs, helping people with disabilities, and aiding with search and rescue efforts.
- 2018 Festival
- Science
The early years of domesticated dogs
Humans like to think they had a hand in turning wolves into gentle domesticated creatures. Not so, says canine cognition expert Brian Hare. Wolves were domesticated between 15,000 and 25,000 years ago when humans began living in greater density. “We did what we still do today with great alacrity — produce a lot of garbage.”
It was easy pickings. And dogs were particularly interested in human feces. In fact, excrement played a major role in the domestication of dogs. “Think of human feces as like, an energy bar for a wolf,” says Hare. “It’s cooked, digested, it doesn’t run away, and it has more protein than chicken.”
Bonding with a dog is akin to bonding with a newborn
Don’t stare into the eyes of a wolf, warns dog researcher Alexandra Horowitz. “That’s a threat, but dogs have changed from that.” Dogs love to gaze into the eyes of their owners because they get an oxytocin rush. Oxytocin, the hormone that’s produced to encourage bonding with a newborn, is also present in dogs and humans when they make eye contact.
Big IdeaWe pet dogs and we get this surge of oxytocin. They’ve hitchhiked onto our feelings toward our infants, and they get the oxytocin rush too.Alexandra Horowitz
Do dogs have dreams or nightmares?
If you and your dog watched a horror movie together, can you tell later in the evening if he’s having a nightmare? Scientists say, unfortunately not. It’s tough to measure whether dogs are counting kibble or running from zombies, says canine scientist Brian Hare. We may not know the content of their dreams, he says, but we know sleep is important. Data show dogs that are getting trained perform better after a good night’s sleep.
Big IdeaThe activation that happens at night [for dogs] does help them consolidate memories and learn new things. So, sleep is just as important for dogs as it is for people.Brian Hare
Do dogs feel guilt?
Turns out dogs do experience basic emotions like fear, anger, and pleasure. What’s harder to pinpoint is whether canines feel secondary, or more complex, emotions such as guilt. Alexandra Horowitz, psychology professor at Barnard College, created an experiment to find out.
For her guilt test, Horowitz had dog owners enter a room and forbid their dogs to eat a piece of food, and then owners left. If the dog had consumed the treat upon their return, the owner would scold them. If they left the treat alone, the owner would greet them. "I didn’t see more guilty look when the dog was guilty. What I saw was more guilty look when the owner started getting angry.” Her conclusion: the dog didn’t know they violated the rules of the house but they did understand their owner was angry. “[The guilty look] is an expression of appeasement. ‘I’m concerned you look angry and I want to put on this really cute look.’”
Explore More
Science


A technological future where our brain waves could be monitored and our thoughts decoded and analyzed — sometimes against our will — is not as far away as we think. But our ex...

Setting audacious goals helps to redefine what is achievable in health, medicine, and science. As we deepen understanding of the human genome, unravel the mysteries of the bra...

What does the latest in neuroscience tell us about human health and consciousness? Aspen Ideas Festival speakers explore how biology is being integrated with technology in unp...

At the 2023 Aspen Ideas Festival, we dug into some of the most important and fascinating issues of our time, from rebuilding trust in our institutions and the promise and peri...

A.I. can find meaningful patterns in otherwise unintelligible noise, so scientists are starting to wonder: Can A.I. help humans interpret animal sounds? Scientist Karen Bakker...

DOORS OPEN AT 6PM. In the film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Kate Winslet’s character erases painful memories of her ex-boyfriend. Could this be possible in real life...

Stories matter, as do the ways we tell them. Hear from the founder of an audiobook empire and a renowned theoretical physicist on the art and power of capturing and conveying...

The Afternoon of Conversation is the Aspen Ideas Festival's pinnacle programming moment. Over 2,000 people gather in the Benedict Music Tent, an open-air venue with acoustics...

The decline in trust of scientific institutions over the course of the pandemic is manifested in the number of Americans worried about the truth of scientific progress and the...

The mysteries of brain health are hidden deep within the ridges and grooves of the cerebral cortex. Join Mount Sinai Health System neuroscientists in this discussion of new te...

From the first galaxies that grew after the Big Bang, to black holes swallowing their neighbors, to stars and planets being born today in the Cosmic Cliffs, the James Webb Spa...

Featuring three one-on-one conversations, our tenth anniversary closing session is not to be missed! We begin with comedian Iliza Shlesinger, who opens up to bestselling autho...

The world has renewed hope that impactful treatments for Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias may finally be on the horizon. While previous therapies have modestly improv...

Vision, hearing, touch, taste, and smell are the five human senses most of us are fortunate enough to know intimately. We like to say that intuition is our sixth sense, but Em...

When it comes to biomedical research, Earth’s gravity can be an obstacle, making it harder to program stem cells into viable organs, obscuring the crystalline structure of pro...

The belief that the paralyzed will walk and the deaf will hear is a staple of religion, literature, and myth. Now, technology is actually making that happen. Zeen has designed...

Research that can generate transformative, high-impact biomedical and health breakthroughs, from the molecular to the societal, is gaining traction as the Advanced Research Pr...

Will AI bring in robot doctors? Chat GPT: “Yes, these robots can assist in various healthcare tasks, such as diagnosing illnesses, performing surgeries, or providing personali...

For many women reaching middle age, menopause is a liberating signal that the childbearing years have come to an end. But with its characteristic hot flashes and complex effec...

Although essential to ensure the safety and effectiveness of new drugs and devices, clinical trials tend to be costly and slow to reach conclusions, and there is often an imb...