

The Chief: The Life and Turbulent Times of Chief Justice John Roberts
Setup
Is the current chief justice of the United States a conservative activist, or a neutral umpire concerned first and foremost with preserving the institution of the Supreme Court? He may be a bit of both. An acclaimed recent biography, by a journalist who has known and observed Roberts for two decades, contends that Roberts is torn between two, often divergent, priorities: to carry out a conservative agenda, and to protect the court’s image and his place in history—a duality that has sowed distrust among his colleagues and anxiety about where he’s taking the court.
- 2019 Festival
- USA
Learning from failure: the SCOTUS edition
Even those who disagree with Supreme Court chief justice John Roberts on the issues usually can’t find fault with his intelligence and skill as legal mind, says Joan Biskupic, legal analyst and author of a biography about Roberts. Roberts quickly rose to prominence through Harvard Law School and the Reagan administration, cementing his reputation. But Biskupic explains how it was one of his few failures that helped him reach the Supreme Court:
Roberts the institutionalist v. Roberts the idealist
There are two competing impulses that drive John Roberts’ judicial decisions, says Joan Biskupic. One side of John Roberts is idealistically conservative — he did, after all, cut his teeth working for the Reagan administration. Another side of Roberts, though, believes vehemently in protecting the legitimacy of the Supreme Court. And in Roberts’ view, contentious decisions about polarizing issues damage the legitimacy of the Supreme Court in the public eye.
Did you know?
Biskupic says that because these impulses are often competing, Roberts has to balance his personal ideology with the realities presented to him on a literal case-by-case basis. And despite his best intentions, he often ends up confounding outside observers with decisions that sometimes fail both his ideology and his concerns for the court.
He’s smart, but is he likable?
Likeability might seem like a superficial trait for such an esteemed institution, but the quality of personal relationships between Supreme Court justices can have very real implications for how decisions are reached. Joan Biskupic says that John Roberts’ inexperience and ideological inconsistency have sown confusion and distrust amongst his fellow justices:
The “all in good time” chief justice
It’s clear that chief justice John Roberts trusts himself above all to make momentous decisions, but how does he actually reach those decisions? In response to an audience question about how to characterize John Roberts’ decision making style, Joan Biskupic breaks down how her analysis:
Learn More
Additional Information
Resources
The Chief: The Life and Turbulent Times of Chief Justice John Roberts by Joan Biskupic
Explore More
USA

Meet Patience Lee, a 2023 Aspen Ideas: Health Fellow who’s building cultural awareness into mental health support services for unaccompanied refugee children in the United Sta...

Meet Nathan Chomilo, a 2023 Aspen Ideas: Health Fellow who’s incorporating community collaboration and racial equity into Minnesota’s Medicaid policy development.













The pandemic put into stark relief deeply-ingrained gender roles in society, as the burden of unpaid care fell to millions of women who left the workforce. Yet the past years...

Of course, Black history shouldn’t just be a month-long nod on our yearly calendar — it is inextricable from American history and fundamental to the very soul of our nation an...

Politics are a frenzy right now, with bombshell headlines dropping so often that it’s hard to know what to focus on. Even when you can cut through the noise, what you hear is...





From the Supreme Court's ruling on abortion rights to public health's role in addressing gun violence to the devastating human toll of the war in Ukraine, this year's Aspen Id...


From blockchain to back to school and virus-hunting to bridging divides, speakers at the 2021 Aspen Ideas Festival addressed issues in a new kind of world—one touched, and cha...

The highest court often seems distanced from our day-to-day lives, but the rulings that come out of the Supreme Court are woven into the fabric of the nation. Though it aims t...

Gen-Z for Change's Aidan Kohn-Murphy on youth-led movements, his advice for young activists, and why it's impossible to lose hope.



