Posers: Why the Firestorm?

Rachel Dolezal is a white woman who has identified as African American. Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren has identified as Native American. Both women have expressed feelings of solidarity for demographic groups that some would argue they ought not claim as their own. What’s wrong with claiming to belong to a historically subordinated population group? This spring, Rebecca Tuvel published an essay, “In Defense of Transracialism,” in the respected academic philosophy journal, Hypatia. The article offended many, who attacked its thesis and an argument comparing transrace to transgender. The judgment of the journal editors who selected the essay for publication — only to then apologize profusely for having done so — was also attacked. What went wrong? Is there a moral future for transracialism in a world of ambiguous phenotypes and editable DNA?

Speakers: Anita Allen
Festival: Aspen Ideas 2017

Watch and Listen: U.S.A.

Wonder what you ever did before Hamilton came along? So do we! Join us for a lively and informal behind-the-scenes look... See more
New legislation in front of Congress would make it legal to carry a concealed, loaded firearm from any state into any... See more
Norman Lear is the prolific television writer and producer of stories about diverse American life—among them “All in... See more
With nearly 40 million people, the innovation powerhouse of Silicon Valley, and the sixth-largest economy in the world... See more
Ideas about living a moral life can be found in all cultures across time. In previous eras, education was meant to... See more
American women have lived their daily lives — before and after the epic election of 2016 and its accompanying drama —... See more